Spencer Stuart: Approach to Executive Search

— PIXCELL

SEARCHING FOR TALENT?

WE CAN HELP

Which Firm Fits You Best?

In the world of executive search, the five largest companies that dominate globally are: Spencer Stuart, Heidrick & Struggles, Russell Reynolds, Egon Zehnder, and Korn Ferry, commonly referred to as the "SHREK" firms. All these companies are based in the United States, except for Egon Zehnder (Switzerland). The boards of directors of the largest global companies (Fortune 500) instinctively turn to these organizations when recruiting senior executives. On the other hand, the executive search field also includes several boutique firms that are part of an international network, such as CFR Global Executive Search. While the SHREK firms have a competitive advantage in terms of size, boutique firms stand out in various ways: specialized sector or functional expertise, close client relationships, use of artificial intelligence, or advanced technologies to improve efficiency and speed, among others. So, which approach, or organization will suit you best?

Spencer Stuart is a global executive search firm based in the US in Chicago, Illinois. With more than 60 years of experience, it is the largest privately held search firm in the world.

In this article, we’ll look at the pros and cons of Spencer Stuart recruitment, including Spencer Stuart’s Canada locations, and how they compare with local firms like PIXCELL.

Spencer Stuart’s Recruitment Approach

Spencer Stuart has a global network spanning 70 offices in more than 33 countries, including Canadian locations in Calgary, Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver. Spencer Stuart Montreal, for example, has five consultants and four senior associates in its office.

While executive search is their primary business, they also offer additional services, such as:

Leadership consulting and assessment
Board services and succession planning
Digital and technology leadership solutions
Diversity and inclusion initiatives

Pros and Cons of Spencer Stuart’s Recruitment Strategy

Like any firm, Spencer Stuart’s recruiting approach comes with both advantages and disadvantages.

Strengths

Extensive Global Network: Spencer Stuart has a broad global network, allowing access to top-tier candidates across various industries and regions.
Industry Expertise: Spencer Stuart recruiting is organized into specialized practice areas, such as technology, healthcare, finance, and consumer goods.
Leadership Consulting: Beyond Spencer Stuart executive search services, the firm also provides leadership advisory services, such as board effectiveness reviews and succession planning,
Rigorous Assessment Process: The firm uses competency-based interviews and psychometric assessments to find qualified candidates that also align with organizational culture.
Confidentiality and Discretion: At the executive level, confidentiality is crucial. Spencer Stuart’s recruiting team is known for handling sensitive searches with the necessary discretion, especially when sourcing candidates from competitors.
Focus on Diversity: The executive search firm has placed a strong emphasis on diversity in recent years, helping companies identify and hire diverse talent for leadership positions, which is critical for innovation and representation.

Challenges

Cost: Spencer Stuart recruitment is expensive, making them less accessible to many businesses. Their fees are typically based on a percentage of the candidate's first-year salary, which can be substantial at the C-suite level.
Longer Recruitment Timelines: Due to the thoroughness of their search process and the seniority of the positions they handle, recruitment timelines can be longer than with other firms. This can be a drawback for organizations needing to fill roles quickly.
Exclusive Focus on Top-Level Positions: Spencer Stuart’s recruitment primarily focuses on C-suite and upper management roles. This limits their usefulness to organizations looking for mid-level or entry-level talent.
Reliance on Traditional Methods: Some critics argue that Spencer Stuart relies heavily on established networks and may not always be as agile in adopting new technologies as other firms focused on tech innovation in recruitment.
Cultural Fit Limitations: While they do assess for cultural fit, their focus on elite candidates may sometimes lead to the selection of individuals who fit traditional leadership models. This is fine for many organizations, but may not be a good fit for rapidly changing, innovative, or diverse organizational cultures.
Limited Transparency: Like many top executive search firms, Spencer Stuart recruitment services operate with a high level of confidentiality, which can sometimes mean less transparency for both clients and candidates throughout the recruitment process.

Spencer Stuart vs. PIXCELL

While Spencer Stuart’s executive search services have global reach, PIXCELL leverages its deep understanding of the Canadian business landscape for highly targeted solutions.

Global vs. Local

Executive search based in Montreal, PIXCELL has significant experience and local expertise with Quebec’s unique culture and bilingual requirements. Combining a local with global reach provides broad access to local, regional, and global talent pools. As part of CFR Global Executive Search, a network of executive search firms, PIXCELL has access to talent in nearly every market worldwide.

There are advantages to working with smaller, boutique executive search firms. You have more access to senior leadership and the most experienced executive recruiters working on your behalf.

A Personalized Approach

Especially for Canadian businesses, you get a much more personalized approach and dedicated attention throughout the entire search process. This produces a high-touch approach to your search needs. You get more regular interactions, transparency, and direct communication with business leaders.

Based on search parameters, PIXCELL creates a tailored search strategy that fits your needs. PIXCELL’s talent search specialists have deep executive search experience across various industries, including:

Information technology and digital transformation
Manufacturing and engineering
Public and para-public sectors
Retail and distribution
Real estate and construction
Financial services
Pharmaceutical and life sciences
Professional services, including law, engineering consulting, finance, and strategy

Final Thoughts

Spencer Stuart’s global prominence may be a good solution for multinational corporations. Businesses operating in Montreal, Toronto, or Quebec may benefit more from PIXCELL’s knowledge of Canadian markets.

PIXCELL is a top-tier executive search firm with global reach, but also provides the personal touch associated with a boutique firm. This produces a more personal, customized, and agile approach.

Your Industry. Our Expertise in Senior Executive Recruitment.

Our talent search specialists are not only leaders in their field but also well versed in industry-specific business concerns. Over the years, our executive recruitment firm has developed a vast network of Canadian and international partners to provide you with fast, privileged access to the best candidates in your industry.